17 May 2010
MD&A Financial Results: 1Q10
Central Pattana Public Company Limited
Management's Discussion and Analysis
Consolidated Financial Results: 1Q10
Overall Performance
Comparison between 1Q10 and 1Q09 performance should be done under the
consideration that partial performance of CentralPlaza Pinklao and the two
office towers at CentralPlaza Pinklao Project has been transferred to CPN
Retail Growth Leasehold Property Fund ("CPNRF") since November 2009 due to the
financial lease of most of the assets of those properties to CPNRF. This was
one of the main contributions to the changes in the company's performance when
comparing this year's performance to that of the same period of the previous
year.
Noted that there were three non-recurring items of totaling 3,765.9 MB
(2,497.9 MB net of tax) incorporated in 4Q09 financial results:
1) A gain of 3,206.9 MB from the financial lease of the assets at
CentralPlaza Pinklao to CPNRF.
2) A one-time income of 659.0 MB.
3) A 100 MB sponsorship expense for a development of a public park next to
CentralWorld Project.
In addition, during the course of 1Q10 the company had reversed a bad debt
provision. This led to two non-recurring items of totaling 340.0 MB (280.9 MB
net of tax) accounted in 1Q10 financial results:
1) Income from reversal of bad debt of 162.7 MB.
2) Interest income of 177.3 MB.
(Please refer to notes to the financial statements for the quarter ended 31
March 2010, no.3).
Central Pattana Public Company Limited ("CPN") reported its 1Q10 consolidated
net profit of 950.8 MB, up 57.6% y-o-y and down 70.4% q-o-q. The q-o-q decline
was attributed to the non-recurring income from the financial lease of assets
to CPNRF reported in 4Q09. Likewise, consolidated total revenues registered
3,290.5 MB, representing a growth of 19.3% y-o-y and a drop of 53.1% q-o-q.
Without the non-recurring items, consolidated total revenues in 1Q10 would
have increased by 13.4% y-o-y, with a solid growth in net profit of 11.1%
y-o-y. These improvements were assisted by additional contribution from the
new projects and stronger performance of CentralWorld upon lowering its rental
discount. On a q-o-q basis, without the extraordinary items, 1Q10 consolidated
revenues would have decreased marginally by 0.9%, mainly due to the absence of
performance of the assets transferred to CPNRF in November 2009, while net
profit would have grown 12.0% as there was significant marketing & promotion
spending for New Year celebrations and the grand opening of CentralPlaza
Khonkean in 4Q09.
Noted that normally a new project yields lower margin than a mature one. This
is due to its relatively lower occupancy rate and special rental discount
given to assist tenants at a new mall during its initial stage. In light of
nascent economy recovery, lower rental discounts were achieved at CentralWorld
and most of the new projects while matured projects experienced increases in
rental rates and service income. Nonetheless, prolong political unrest for a
certain degree is still a drawback on consumer spending. To ensure that cash
flow remains steady and is well reserved for under-developing projects and any
unforeseen liquidity needs, CPN implemented cost-saving campaigns with expense
management through top-line driven basis in addition to adding extra retail
carts and kiosks in its retail properties to attain extra rental income.
New Developments
During 2010 - 2012, CPN anticipated four green-field projects to come on-line.
These include
1) Hilton Pattaya Beach Hotel, the hotel component of CentralFestival Pattaya
Beach Project-east of Thailand,2) CentralPlaza Chiangrai - north of Thailand,
3) CentralPlaza Rama IX-Bangkok, and 4) CentralFestival Chiangmai - north of
Thailand. Constructions of Hilton Pattaya Beach Hotel and CentralPlaza Rama IX
are progressing as per schedule. The projects are due to complete in 3Q10 and
4Q11, respectively. For the other two projects, land banks were secured while
detailed feasibility studies were under works.
These new developments will be funded by internal cash flow, fund raised
through CPNRF,and long-term bank loans. Thanks to the company's strong track
record and its A+ credit rating, CPN currently has 4,000 MB in short-term
credit facilities available and secured long-term loans from banks with
available credit line of 3,350 MB.
Operational Performance
As at March 31, 2010, CPN managed 15 projects (9 projects in Bangkok and 6
projects in provinces). These comprise of 15 shopping centers (totaling
808,839 sqm of leasable area), 6 office towers (totaling 129,984 sqm of
leasable area), 2 residential projects (totaling 62 units), and 1 hotel (255
guest rooms). The above leasable areas exclude retail area of CentralPlaza
Rama 2, CentralPlaza Ratchada-Rama 3, and CentralPlaza Pinklao, totaling
157,589 sqm, and office area of totaling 33,762 sqm of Pinklao Tower A and B,
which have been transferred to CPN Retail Growth Leasehold Property Fund
("CPNRF") of which CPN acts as the property manager.
For CPN own retail properties, occupancy rate averaged 95%, down from 96% in
4Q09. Effective rental rate of retail space averaged 1,252 Bt/sqm/mth, down
1.5% y-o-y and flat q- o-q. This was primarily attributed to lower rental
rates of new provincial malls in addition to special rental discounts given to
tenants at the new malls during their initial stage. For comparative purpose,
excluding the five new malls launched during the course of 2008 - 2009,
effective rental rate was up 3.2% y-o-y and 1.3% q-o-q to an average of 1,329
Bt/sqm/mth.
Occupancy rate for CPN own offices averaged 82%, down from 86% in 4Q09.
Take-up rate of CentralPlaza Lardprao's office tower was declining upon the
project approaching its closing date for major renovation. Occupancy rate of
the office building at its CentralPlaza Chaengwattana stood at 29%, up from
26% in 4Q09. Due to its nature of being an office property, which normally
takes approximately 2 years for a building to reach its 80% occupancy rate;
hence, low take-up rate of the Chaengwattana's office at its initial stage is
considered normal. The remaining space is expected to be leased out by 2011.
Table 1: Operation Statistics
Retail Shopping Centers Net Leaseable Occupancy Rate (%)
Area (Sqm.) 1Q09 4Q09 1Q10
Ladprao 55,583 97% 97% 94%
Ramindra 17,159 99% 100% 99%
Pinklao 37,463 97% 98% 100%
Pattaya Center 15,226 100% 98% 97%
Ratchada-Rama3 18,192 99% 99% 99%
Chiangmai 75,889 99% 99% 99%
Bangna 57,695 98% 98% 99%
Rama2 5,937 100% 100% 100%
Rattanathibet 76,938 98% 99% 98%
CentralWorld 187,028 97% 96% 95%
Chaengwattana 65,581 92% 91% 90%
Pattaya Beach Festival 56,826 88% 89% 90%
Udon Thani 49,452 n/a 98% 98%
Chonburi 40,409 n/a 92% 90%
Khonkaen 49,461 n/a 87% 91%
Total 808,839 96% 96% 95%
Note: CentralPlaza Rama 2, CentralPlaza Ratchada-Rama 3, CentralPlaza Pinklao
were partially leased out to CPNRF
Offices Net Leaseable Occupancy Rate (%)
Area (Sqm.) 1Q09 4Q09 1Q10
Ladprao 17,719 97% 96% 71%
Bangna 10,007 92% 95% 95%
CentralWorld 82,796 95% 95% 95%
Chaengwattana 19,462 8% 26% 29%
Total 129,984 84% 85% 82%
Note: Pinklao Tower A & B offices were leased out to CPNRF
Financial Performance
Total Revenues
Rental and Service Income
In property business, 1Q10 rental and service income registered 2,734.9 MB,
grew 11.6% y- o-y, primarily from the openings of three new projects -
CentralPlaza Undonthani (acquired in 2Q09), CentralPlaza Chonburi (opened in
2Q09), and CentralPlaza Khonkean (opened in 4Q09) in addition to continuous
increase in rental rates at all properties.
On a q-o-q basis, rental and service income gained 5.0%, mainly driven by a
full quarter revenue contribution from CentralPlaza Khonkean and an
incremental rental incomes from CentralFestival Pattaya Beach and CentralWorld
upon lowering discount rates.
Food and Beverage Sales
In food center business, 1Q10 food and beverage sales drop 8.1% y-o-y and
12.8% q-o-q to 135.1 MB upon improving market sentiment, which led to change
in dinning behavior as shoppers dine more at restaurants. CPN had captured
such changes in dinning behavior by increasing numbers of restaurants and food
parlors in shopping centers which, in return, yielded more rental incomes to
the company.
Revenues from Hotel Operations
Revenues from hotel operations in 1Q10 registered 37.0 MB. Occupancy rate
stood at 68%, unchanged from 4Q09 while revenue per available room (RevPAR)
was flat q-o-q.
Other Income
Other income consisted of incomes from costs charged back to tenants (such as
property tax, insurance premiums, renovation costs, etc.), event sponsorships,
and other non-recurring incomes.
1Q10 other income amounted to 383.5 MB, up 141.0% y-o-y but down 90.9% q-o-
q, due to the inclusion of non-recurring incomes in 1Q10 and 4Q09 performance.
The 4Q09 other income incorporated with non-recurring items; 1) a gain of
3,206.9 MB from the financial lease of CentralPlaza Pinklao to CPNRF, and 2) a
one-time income of 659.0 MB. During 1Q10, CPN had received a principal
repayment of 162.7 MB from a doubtful account, of which a provision was
reversed and booked under "Other Income" while its associated interest charge
of 177.3 MB was accounted for under "Interest Income."
(Please refer to notes to the financial statements for the quarter ended 31
March 2010, no.3).
Total Cost
Total cost of rental & service and food & beverage included utilities,
depreciation and amortization of rented properties, on-site personnel, repair
& maintenance and property tax.
In 1Q10 consolidated total cost amounted to 1,746.3 MB, up 15.1% y-o-y, due to
additional operating costs and depreciation and amortization expenses of the
new projects previously mentioned. On a q-o-q basis, total cost declined 2.6%
mainly from lower repair and maintenance cost.
Total Operating and Administration Expenses
Total operating and administration expenses constituted expenses on personnel,
marketing and promotion costs, office supplies, professional fees,
depreciation and amortization of office equipments.
Total operating and administration expenses for 1Q10 stood at 459.7 MB, up
11.9% y-o-y, from increased number of employees to support business
expansion. Compared to the previous quarter, the expenses were down 40.2% as
4Q09 operating and administration expenses were inclusive of a one-time
sponsorship of 100.0 MB for the development of a public park next to
CentralWorld Project. Excluding this extraordinary item, operating and
administration expenses would have declined 31.3% q-o-q as there were
significant marketing & promotion spending for New Year celebrations and the
grand opening of CentralPlaza Khonkean in 4Q09.
Net Profit
Without the non-recurring items, 1Q10 consolidated net profit would have
amounted 670.0 MB, increased by 11.1% y-o-y on additional contribution from
new projects and stronger performance of CentralWorld, and grown by 12.0%
q-o-q, primarily attributed to increased revenues and lower marketing and
promotion spending as previously mentioned.
Table 2: Consolidated Results Summary
Consolidated Result 1Q09 4Q09Adj 1Q10 1Q10Adj YoY%Chg QoQ%Chg
(Bt mil)
Revenues 2,757.2 3,155.9 3,290.5 3,127.8 13.4% (0.9%)
Retail 2,225.3 2,366.7 2,538.8 2,538.8 14.1% 7.3%
Office 218.7 232.0 189.1 189.1 (13.5%) (18.5%)
Hotel 0.0 41.4 37.0 37.0 n/a (10.6%)
F&B 147.0 155.0 135.1 135.1 (8.1%) (12.8%)
Other rental income 7.1 6.3 7.0 7.0 (0.8%) 11.5%
Other income 159.1 354.5 383.5 220.7 38.7% (37.7%)
Costs 1,517.5 1,793.8 1,746.3 1,746.3 15.1% (2.6%)
Retail 1,248.6 1,498.6 1,484.2 1,484.2 18.9% (1.0%)
Office 141.0 142.4 126.3 126.3 (10.4%) (11.3%)
Hotel 0.0 15.0 13.7 13.7 n/a (8.5%)
F&B 121.3 131.3 115.5 115.5 (4.8%) (12.0%)
Other rental income 6.5 6.6 6.6 6.6 2.0% (0.2%)
Interest income 11.2 4.5 183.5 6.3 (44.0%) 39.1%
Operating profit 840.3 697.8 1,268.0 928.0 10.4% 33.0%
Net profit 603.2 598.5 950.8 670.0 11.1% 12.0%
EPS (Bt) 0.28 0.27 0.44 0.31 11.1% 12.0%
Capital Structure
As at March 31, 2010, interest-bearing debts stood at 16,642.0 MB, relatively
unchanged from that of FY2009 while net interest-bearing debts declined by
4.0% to 13,557.1 MB and comprised of 68% fixed and 32% floating interest
rate. Net interest-bearing debt to equity ratio was 0.7 times, unchanged from
that of FY2009.
1Q10 interest expenses and financial charges amounted to 168.2 MB, up 4.9%
y-o-y and down 11.9% q-o-q, with a weighted average cost of debts of 4.4% per
annum, compared to 4.8% in 1Q09 and 4.4% in 4Q09.
Table 3: Financial Position
Balance Sheet (Bt mil) 1Q09 4Q09 1Q10 %Chg YoY %Chg QoQ
Total Assets 46,360.7 50,895.4 51,540.2 11.2% 1.3%
Current Assets 4,487.5 3,937.2 4,609.2 2.7% 17.1%
Property&Equipment(PP&E) 33,138.0 38,433.5 38,405.9 15.9% (0.1%)
Leasehold Right 5,274.5 4,443.1 4,248.8 (19.4%) (4.4%)
Total Liabilities 30,586.7 31,887.3 31,577.9 3.2% (1.0%)
Interest-Bearing Debts 16,160.0 16,669.4 16,642.0 3.0% (0.2%)
Shareholder's Equity 15,774.0 19,008.1 19,962.3 26.6% 5.0%
Retained earnings 10,910.4 14,539.8 15,490.7 42.0% 6.5%
Table 4: Key Financial Ratios
Key Financial Ratios 1Q09 4Q09 1Q10
Liquidity ratio
Current ratio (times) 0.5 0.6 0.7
Quick ratio (times) 0.4 0.4 0.5
Days account receivable (days) 17.8 11.9 12.4
Profitability ratio
Gross profit margin (%) 45.0% 43.2% 44.2%
Net profit margin (%) 21.1% 17.8% 20.6%
Return on equity (%) 16.3% 14.0% 14.0%
Efficiency ratio
Return on assets (%) 5.4% 4.8% 5.2%
Financial policy ratio
Net debt to equity (times) 0.8 0.7 0.7
Net debt to EBITDA (times) 2.5 2.7 2.5
Interest coverage /1 (times) 8.1 8.6 6.2
Note: /1Cash generated from operation excludes cash payment of endorsed
promissory notes