16 August 2010
MD&A Financial Results: 2Q10
Central Pattana Public Company Limited
Management's Discussion and Analysis
Consolidated Financial Results: 2Q10
Overall Performance
Central Pattana Public Company Limited ("CPN") announced its 2Q10 interim
financial statements with an auditor's qualified opinion on damages from the
fire incidents at CentralWorld Shopping Complex, which have not yet been
concluded. (Please refer to the Review Report of Certified Public Accountant
to the financial statements for the quarter ended June 30, 2010.)
In 2Q10, CPN reported its consolidated net profit of 164.5 MB, representing a
72.0% y-o-y and 82.7% q-o-q decrease. 2Q10 total revenues registered 2,486.0
MB, declined by 16.5% y-o-y and 24.4% q-o-q. The changes in the CPN's
performance when comparing this quarter's performance to those of the previous
quarter and the same period of last year were primarily due to the following
distinct sources:
1) An absence of revenue from CentralWorld Shopping Center since the April
2010, due to the closure of the property. (See the "CentralWorld " section)
2) A one-month rent-free at The Offices at CentralWorld due to difficulty
of access during political gatherings at nearby area.
3) A transfer of partial assets of CentralPlaza Pinklao and the two
offices at CentralPlaza Pinklao Project to CPN Retail Growth Leasehold
Property Fund ("CPNRF") since November 2009.
4) An inclusion of a one-time gain of 66.0 MB (42.6 MB net of tax) from an
acquisition of additional investment units in the Thai Business Fund 4 in the
2Q09 performance.
5) Non-recurring incomes of totaling 340.0 MB (280.9 MB net of tax)
incorporated in the 1Q10 financial results from reversal of a bad debt and its
associated interest income.
The first distinction had the most adverse attribution to the 2Q10 performance
as the property was the largest revenue contributor while parts of its
operating costs and expenses were fixed.
As for operational performance, occupancy rates remained high at an average of
95% for retail properties and 81% for offices. Y-o-Y rental increases were
achieved at almost all of the company's properties, though at low pace. On a
q-o-q basis, few properties experienced a marginal drop in effective rental
rate on the backdrop of political unrests.
Development plans for under construction projects, namely Hilton Pattaya Beach
Hotel, CentralPlaza Chiangrai, CentralPlaza Pitsanulok, and CentralPlaza Rama
IX, remained intact. Likewise, the company's business expansion plan continued
moving forward. A land plot in Surat Thani Province (South of Thailand) was
acquired in 2Q10 for near-term development.
Although the company has invested a large capital expenditure, financial
position remained solid. Net interest-bearing debt to equity ratio was 0.8
times. This was due to a prudent financing policy, where funding mainly came
from operating cash flow and cash proceeds from properties leased to CPNRF.
CentralWorld
During the 2Q10, there was a political demonstration nearby CentralWorld
Project. The demonstration ended with fire incidents at CentralWorld Shopping
Complex on May 19, 2010, causing damages to most of the Zen Department Store,
a long-term leasee, and parts of the CentralWorld Shopping Complex. As a
result of the political demonstration, CPN has closed down the complex since
April 2010 for the safety of shoppers and tenants, and consequently, CPN has
not charged rent to tenants since then.
CentralWorld Project is protected by Industrial All Risk, business
interruption and terrorism insurances. The management believes that the
damages are fully covered by the insurance policies while the compensation for
lost revenues after the fire incidents until the operation resumes as normal
is expected to be compensated in full under terms and conditions of the
business interruption insurance.
At present, the insurers are investigating and assessing the actual damage,
which is expected to be concluded by 4Q10. Until then, CPN has not yet
recorded any impairment losses of assets and expected compensation from
claims in its 2Q10 financial statements. (Please refer to notes to the
financial statements for the quarter ended June 30, 2010, no.18).
Nevertheless, during the closure of the complex and with the absence of its
revenues, CPN incurred parts of operating costs and expenses related to this
property, and accounted them in the company's 2Q10 financial statements.
Though CPN has not yet received any compensation from claims, renovation and
reconstruction works at the complex have proactively begun. Isetan Department
Store, which was unharmed by the fire, was back in business, and by December
2010, most of CentralWorld Shopping Complex will be re-opened. As for the Zen
Department Store, which requires approximately 14 months for reconstruction,
its operation will resume in 3Q11.
As a result of the fire incidents, CPN has postponed the plan to close down
CentralPlaza Lardprao Shopping Complex as well as its enhancement project to
1Q11 to ensure a steady cash flow.
Operational Performance Summary
As at June 30, 2010, CPN managed 15 shopping centers (9 projects in Bangkok
and 6 projects in provinces), 6 office towers, 2 residential properties, and 1
hotel. These include the properties which have been transferred to CPNRF, of
which CPN acts as the property manager.
For CPN's retail properties, occupancy rate in 2Q10 averaged 95%, excluding
CentralWorld's. For CentralPlaza Lardprao, occupancy rate fell to 87% as some
tenants moving out prior to the postponement of its major renovation project.
Effective rental rate (for retail tenants) stood at 1,201 Bt/sqm/mth, down
2.6% y-o-y, reflecting lower effective rental rates of new provincial
projects. Excluding CentralWorld and the five newly opened projects, the other
projects achieved an average 1.0% y-o-y growth in effective rent.
Despite the postponement of renovation plan at CentralPlaza Lardprao Shopping
Complex, enhancement project of its office tower has pushed forward, resulting
in temporary decrease in occupancy rate. For the latest office project at
Chaengwattana, take-up rate jumped from 29% in the preceding quarter to 53%
in 2Q10 mainly from a new anchor tenant. It is a nature of office property
that normally takes approximately 2 years for a building to fill-up 80% of its
space; hence, low take-up rate of the Chaengwattana's office at its initial
stage is considered normal. The remaining space is expected to be leased out
by 2011.
Table 1: Operation Statistics
Retail Shopping Centers Net Leaseable Occupancy Rate (%)
Area (Sqm.) 2Q09 1Q10 2Q10
Ladprao 55,583 97% 94% 87%
Ramindra 17,160 100% 99% 100%
Pinklao 37,463 98% 100% 100%
Pattaya Center 15,226 99% 97% 97%
Ratchada-Rama3 18,192 99% 99% 100%
Chiangmai 75,873 99% 99% 99%
Bangna 57,695 98% 99% 99%
Rama2 5,937 100% 100% 100%
Rattanathibet 76,938 97% 98% 98%
CentralWorld n/a 97% 95% n/a
Chaengwattana 65,568 93% 90% 91%
Pattaya Beach Festival 56,832 89% 90% 90%
Udon Thani 49,773 100% 98% 98%
Chonburi 40,119 83% 90% 90%
Khonkaen 49,537 n/a 91% 90%
Total 621,896 96% 95% 95%
Note: Excludes assets leased to CPNRF
Offices Net Leaseable Occupancy Rate (%)
Area (Sqm.) 2Q09 1Q10 2Q10
Ladprao 17,719 96% 71% 38%
Bangna 10,007 92% 95% 97%
CentralWorld 82,796 94% 95% 95%
Chaengwattana 19,699 20% 29% 53%
Total 130,221 85% 82% 81%
Note: Excludes assets leased to CPNRF
Financial Performance
Total Revenues
Rental and Service Income
2Q10 rental and service income registered 2,164.9 MB, declined by 14.6% y-o-y
and 20.8% q-o-q, primarily due to the absence of rental and service income
from CentralWorld and the transfer of partial assets of CentralPlaza Pinklao
and the two offices at CentralPlaza Pinklao Project to CPNRF.
For comparative purpose, excluding performance of CentralWorld and
CentralPlaza Pinklao Project in 2Q10 and 2Q09, rental and service income
surged 12.1% y-o-y, mainly supported by the openings of new projects. On a
q-o-q basis, disregard the performance of CentralWorld, rental and service
income declined by 4.5%. The weaker performance was mainly due to the
compound effects of the followings:
a) A one-month rental waive at The Offices at CentralWorld, compensating
the difficulty of access during political gatherings at nearby area.
b) A closure of partial space at the CentralPlaza Lardprao's office tower
for renovation in addition to a lower occupancy rate at CentralPlaza Lardprao
upon approaching its major renovation.
Food and Beverage Sales
For in-mall food center business, Y-o-Y food and beverage sales declined by
21.4% as there were more numbers of mid-end restaurants and food parlors in
the shopping centers. This, in return, yielded higher rental and service
income to the company. Compared to the preceding quarter, almost all of the
food centers performed reasonably well, gaining a fair growth of 5.1%.
Revenues from Hotel Operations
Hotel operations are considered as CPN's non-core businesses, of which
performance was driven by a single asset "Centara Hotel & Convention Center,
Udonthani". Despite a 28.1% y-o-y increase in average room rate to 1,132
Bt/night, revenues from the business shrank by 5.5% y-o-y to 34.3 MB, driven
by a lower occupancy rate of 64% on the backdrop of political tension and
depressed tourism.
Other Income
Other income fell by 36.0% y-o-y and 62.2% q-o-q as there were a one-time
gain of 66.0 MB from acquisition of additional investment units in the Thai
Business Fund 4 in 2Q09 performance and non-recurring income of 162.7 MB
incorporated in the 1Q10 financial results. Excluding the non-recurring items,
2Q10 other income would have dropped 9.6% y- o-y and 34.4% q-o-q, mainly from
the closure of CentralWorld and fewer promotional events during the 2Q10
political tension.
Total Cost
Total cost of rental & service, food & beverage and hotel business included
utilities, depreciation and amortization of rented properties, on-site
personnel, repair & maintenance and property tax.
The effect on the cost side from the closure of CentralWorld was minuscule as
parts of operating costs related to this property were fixed or a must.
However CPN is entitled to claim such costs from the insurance under business
interruption policy.
2Q10 cost of rental & service registered 1,556.1 MB, up 3.5% y-o-y on new
projects and down 3.8% q-o-q. Total costs registered 1,689.2 MB, up 1.4% y-o-y
and down 3.3% q-o-q.
Total Operating and Administration Expenses
Total operating and administration expenses constituted expenses on personnel,
marketing and promotion costs, office supplies, professional fees,
depreciation and amortization of office equipments.
In 2Q10, CPN incurred 436.2 MB of total operating and administration expenses,
decreased by 3.8% y-o-y, primarily due to a) the closure of CentralWorld, b) a
portion of marketing expenses of CentralPlaza Pinklao being transferred to
CPNRF, and c) the inclusion of advertising and promotion expenses for opening
celebration of CentralPlaza Chonburi in the 2Q09 results.
On a q-o-q basis, total operating and administration expenses dropped by 5.1%,
mainly attributed to the closure of CentralWorld and the inclusion of extra
bonus in the 1Q10 personnel expenses.
Net Profit
Without the non-recurring items in 2Q09 and 1Q10, net profit in 2Q10 would
have declined by 69.6% y-o-y and 75.5% q-o-q mainly from the closure of
CentralWorld as mentioned previously.
Table 2: Consolidated Results Summary
Consolidated Result (Bt mil) 2Q09 1Q10 2Q10 YoY%Chg QoQ%Chg
Total Revenues 2,978.1 3,290.5 2,486.0 (16.5%) (24.4%)
Revenues from rental and service 2,534.8 2,734.9 2,164.9 (14.6%) (20.8%)
Retail 2,301.5 2,538.8 2,023.8 (12.1%) (20.3%)
Office 226.3 189.1 133.4 (41.1%) (29.5%)
Other rental income 7.0 7.0 7.7 10.1% 10.1%
Hotel operations 36.3 37.0 34.3 (5.5%) (7.4%)
Food & beverage sales 180.7 135.1 142.0 (21.4%) 5.1%
Other income 226.3 383.5 144.8 (36.0%) (62.2%)
Total Costs 1,666.2 1,746.3 1,689.2 1.4% (3.3%)
Costs of rental and service 1,503.1 1,617.1 1,556.1 3.5% (3.8%)
Retail 1,364.2 1,484.2 1,422.7 4.3% (4.1%)
Office 131.0 126.3 126.4 (3.5%) 0.1%
Other rental income 7.9 6.6 7.0 (11.6%) 5.7%
Hotel operations 15.3 13.7 14.1 (7.6%) 3.1%
Food & beverage sales 147.8 115.5 118.9 (19.5%) 2.9%
Operating profit 864.3 1,268.0 371.8 (57.0%) (70.7%)
Net profit 587.0 950.8 164.4 (72.0%) (82.7%)
EPS (Bt) 0.27 0.44 0.08 (72.0%) (82.7%)
Note: Includes non-recurring items
Capital Structure
During 2Q10, CPN repaid totaling 227.5 MB of long-term borrowings and issued
new debts of totaling 1,850 MB, including 500-MB unsecured bonds (2-yeared
maturity at a coupon of 3- month fixed deposit rate + 1.15% per annum) and
1,350 MB of project financing (7-yeared term at MLR-2.0% per annum). As of
June 30, 2010, interest-bearing debts comprised of 62% fixed and 38% floating
interest rate with a weighted average interest rate of 4.4% per annum.
Although the company has invested a large capital expenditure, financial
position remained solid. Net interest-bearing debt to equity ratio was 0.8
times, lower than the company's policy of one time. As a result of the closure
of CentralWorld, CPN has postponed the enhancement project of CentraPlaza
Lardprao to 1Q11. Nonetheless, other development plans remained intact,
funding through operating cash flow, cash proceeds from property lease to
CPNRF, and long-term bank loans.
Table 3: Financial Position
Balance Sheet (Bt mil) 2Q09 1Q10 2Q10 %YoYChg %QoQChg
Total Assets 49,218.1 51,540.2 51,946.9 5.5% 0.8%
Current assets 4,216.0 4,609.2 4,442.1 5.4% (3.6%)
Property & equipment (PP&E) 36,703.9 38,405.9 39,111.8 6.6% 1.8%
Leasehold right 4,820.3 4,248.8 4,117.7 (14.6%) (3.1%)
Total Liabilities 34,187.6 31,577.9 32,983.6 (3.5%) 4.5%
Interest-bearing debts 19,311.1 16,642.0 18,264.5 (5.4%) 9.7%
Shareholder's Equity 15,030.6 19,962.3 18,963.3 26.2% (5.0%)
Retained earnings 10,778.4 15,490.7 14,391.5 33.5% (7.1%)
Table 4: Key Financial Ratios
Key Financial Ratios 2Q09 1Q10 2Q10
Liquidity ratio
Current ratio (times) 0.6 0.7 0.6
Quick ratio (times) 0.4 0.5 0.5
Days account receivable (days) 16.6 12.4 16.0
Profitability ratio
Gross profit margin (%) 42.8% 44.2% 32.1%
Net profit margin (%) 18.0% 20.6% 6.3%
Return on equity (%) 14.4% 14.0% 3.4%
Efficiency ratio
Return on assets (%) 4.5% 5.2% 1.3%
Financial policy ratio
Net debt to equity (times) 1.1 0.7 0.8
Net debt to EBITDA (times) 3.2 2.5 3.0
Interest coverage /1 (times) 6.5 6.2 6.7
Note:/1 Cash generated from operation excludes cash payment of endorsed
promissory notes